How place-aware app can get lost on WiFi


Some location-conscious apps can get confused on exactly where you are.(Photo: Getty Images)

Q. My phone insists I am a number of hundred miles away from where I am, even even though it had me at the proper spot only an hour ago. How can this take place?

A. Let me guess: You have been indoors, so the telephone had to lean on WiFi signals to estimate its place.

That’s a prevalent way in Android, iOS and other smartphone systems to discern a mobile device’s place. Initial the telephone scans for signals from nearby WiFi routers, then it matches each router’s special hardware address against a database constructed from automated scanning by your phone and other individuals.

This really should operate as lengthy as the WiFi routers in query never move. But if they do and you have a roof over your head blocking GPS, the telephone can choose that you are near where these routers made use of to be.

It is not a new issue–I 1st saw it in 1998 on an EyeFi camera card that relied on WiFi to geotag photos and thus placed a photo taken at two friends’ apartment at their prior abode. But the rising sophistication of phones does not look to have solved it.

Three years ago, for instance, Android tried to place me in a distinct city and then a diverse state alternatively of my appropriate location… at Google’s developer conference in San Francisco. In March, my Android telephone believed I was in an totally separate nation. Weeks later, a buddy with an iPhone 6 in Austin had his phone place him in an additional state.

In every single case, the phone should have been capable to examine WiFi signals to these of nearby cell towers or its last GPS position repair. But it didn’t.

The mobile developers I asked could not say why without having watched my phone each time.

“This could vary on the app and platform,” wrote Justin Miller, lead mobile developer at Mapbox. His colleague Tom Lee added that even developers like him can have a hard time figuring out an error’s cause: “These systems are normally black boxes from a dev’s perspective.”

In iOS, it would at least be easier to assign blame: Apple does not want apps tracking you without the need of you figuring out it, so they ought to ask iOS for the device’s place. And lots of of them, veteran iOS developer W. Dana Nuon observed, employ a power-effective Apple framework that relies on WiFi.

Google gives its own location-detection tools for Android apps, and their mixture of WiFi, GPS and cell-tower signals with a phone accelerometer’s detection of your footsteps need to avert flubs like this. But Google Maps was one particular of the apps that place me in the U.K. alternatively of Spain last month.

Android apps, nevertheless, can select whether or not to take Google’s word for a phone’s location. For instance, Yelp sticks to Android’s estimates though Foursquare also tends to make its own comparison of WiFi signals with its database of venues.

Yet the other app that misplaced me in March was Foursquare.

GPS should yield the most precise study but has its personal flaws.

“When the sky is clear, at evening, and you happen to be in an open dry field, GPS will give you a very correct place signal,” said Phillip Zakas, vice president at SocialRadar. But in cities, GPS signals bounce off pavement and buildings, and wet ground can also dull its accuracy.

Mapbox’s Lee added that if a telephone only sees three of the 24 or so operational Worldwide Positioning Method satellites–a detail place apps hardly ever disclose–it really is more most likely to get lost.

Miller and Nuon both pointed out seeing software program bugs lead to phones to report a GPS place of zero degrees latitude and longitude, off the west coast of Africa. My assistance if you see that on your device: Once you verify that you never have to swim, ask for directions.

Tip: Measure straight-line distances in Google Maps

To rant precisely about your phone’s place mismatch, you will want to cite the straight-line distance involving your spot and your phone’s notion of it. Considering the fact that final July, the desktop version of Google Maps has been in a position to calculate that and any other as-the-crow-flies distance–but it really is hidden behind a ideal-click menu.

To start out, search for a place, right-click its red pushpin icon and choose “Measure Distance,” then click as soon as on the preferred destination (you may possibly need to have to zoom out to see it). You will get an straight-line distance measurement in miles and kilometers. Click again, and you are going to get a second distance measurement… and, probably, the start out of a connect-the-dots drawing.

Rob Pegoraro is a tech writer based out of Washington, D.C. To submit a tech question, e-mail Rob at Comply with him on Twitter at

Our editors found this article on this site using Google and regenerated it for our readers.